Shoplifting Charges in Canada: Penalties, Jail Risk and How to Avoid a Record
Justi Admin
Shoplifting is theft under the Criminal Code, and even a small item can lead to a criminal record. Here is what happens when you are caught, the penalties, and how first-time offenders in Quebec and Ontario often avoid a record through diversion.
Shoplifting is not a separate crime in Canada. It is theft under the Criminal Code, the same offence whether you took a $20 lipstick or a $2,000 laptop. That means a shoplifting charge is a criminal charge, and a conviction leaves a criminal record. The good news: for a first offence involving a small amount, there are often ways to end the case without a record, both in Quebec and in Ontario.
The short answer
- Is shoplifting a crime? Yes. It is theft (sections 322 and 334 of the Criminal Code).
- Can you go to jail? It is possible but rare for a first, low-value offence. Fines, probation or a discharge are far more common.
- Will you have a criminal record? Only if you are convicted. Diversion programs and discharges can avoid one.
- Is it different in Quebec and Ontario? The crime and penalties are the same everywhere in Canada. The diversion programs have different names and rules.
Possible outcomes at a glance:
- Diversion: no conviction, no criminal record.
- Absolute discharge: no conviction; removed from the national database after 1 year.
- Conditional discharge: no conviction; removed after 3 years.
- Fine or probation: conviction and criminal record.
- Jail: conviction and criminal record (rare for a first, low-value theft).
Is shoplifting a crime? What the Criminal Code says
Under section 322 of the Criminal Code, you commit theft when you take something that isn't yours, dishonestly and without any honest claim of right, intending to deprive the owner of it, even temporarily. Shoplifting laws are federal, so the same rules apply in every province. Hiding an item, switching price tags or walking past the cash without paying can all count. Leaving the store is not always required: moving goods with the intent to steal can be enough.
The penalty depends on the value:
- Theft of $5,000 or less (almost all shoplifting): the prosecutor chooses between a summary procedure (the lighter route: maximum two years less a day, a fine of up to $5,000, or both) or an indictable procedure (maximum two years in prison).
- Theft over $5,000: maximum 10 years in prison if prosecuted by indictment (it can also be prosecuted summarily).
These are maximums. They are almost never applied to a first, low-value shoplifting case.
What happens if you get caught shoplifting?
- Store security stops you. The Criminal Code allows the owner of a property, or someone they authorize such as a security guard, to arrest a person they find committing an offence on that property, or within a reasonable time afterwards if police cannot do it. They must then hand you over to the police right away.
- The police decide what to do. They can let you go with a warning, release you with a paper ordering you to appear in court (often with a date for fingerprints), or, rarely, hold you.
- The prosecutor reviews the case. In Quebec, the DPCP (Director of Criminal and Penal Prosecutions) decides whether to authorize a charge. In Ontario, police lay the charge and the Crown Attorney decides whether to continue it, withdraw it or offer diversion.
- Your first court appearance. You receive the evidence (called "disclosure") and decide, ideally with a lawyer, how to respond.
Stay calm and don't sign a written statement. If you are arrested, give your correct name and address: refusing can keep you in custody longer, and a false name is a crime. Beyond that, you have the right to remain silent and to speak to a lawyer right away.
What are the penalties for shoplifting?
For a first offence involving a small amount, the most common outcomes are:
- Diversion (see below): no conviction and no criminal record. Ask a lawyer about having your fingerprints destroyed afterwards.
- Absolute or conditional discharge: you are found guilty, but the judge does not convict you. The discharge is removed from the RCMP's national criminal records database (CPIC) 1 year after an absolute discharge, or 3 years after a conditional discharge is ordered.
- Fine and/or probation: a conviction and a criminal record.
- Jail: unusual for a first, low-value theft, but more likely with repeat offences, high value, organized theft or violence. If force is used to escape, the charge can become robbery, which is far more serious.
A criminal record can make it harder to get some jobs, to travel to the United States, and, if you are not a Canadian citizen, can make you inadmissible. Even a discharge can raise questions at the U.S. border, so get advice before travelling. If you already have a record, a record suspension (pardon) is possible after a waiting period.
Shoplifting in Quebec: how to avoid a criminal record
For a first minor theft, the DPCP can decide not to lay a charge at all and simply send you a warning letter (its non-judicial treatment program). Otherwise, the prosecutor can refer an adult to the General Alternative Measures Program for adults (PMRG). It covers less serious crimes, including minor theft. In general:
- You must accept responsibility for what you did.
- A community justice organization works out a measure with you: for example community service, compensating the victim, mediation, or an awareness or training activity.
- If you complete it, the charge is dismissed: no conviction and no criminal record.
- If you stop the program, the court case resumes.
The prosecutor decides who is eligible. A lawyer can often ask for it, or argue for a discharge if diversion is refused.
Shoplifting in Ontario: how to avoid a criminal record
In Ontario, the main diversion route for adults is the Direct Accountability Program, offered by the Crown Attorney at most Ontario courthouses for minor offences such as theft of $5,000 or less, mostly to people with no record. It works much like Quebec's program:
- You accept responsibility, without pleading guilty in court.
- You complete a sanction: for example restitution, community service, a charitable donation, an educational program or a letter of apology.
- Once you finish, the Crown withdraws the charge (or, less often, stays it), so there is no conviction.
Ontario stores can also ban you from the premises under the province's Trespass to Property Act. Coming back after a ban can lead to a provincial fine of up to $10,000 (not a criminal record).
Need help in Ontario? JustiConnect lists theft and shoplifting lawyers in Ontario, and Legal Aid Ontario may help if your income is low.
How long do police have to lay a charge?
If the prosecutor proceeds by summary conviction, the charge must be laid within 12 months of the theft, unless the prosecutor and the accused both agree to extend it. After 12 months, the prosecutor can still lay the charge, but must proceed by indictment, which has no time limit. In practice, store theft caught on camera is usually charged quickly.
What if the person is under 18?
Minors are dealt with under the Youth Criminal Justice Act, not the adult system. Police must first consider extrajudicial measures (a warning, a referral to a program or an extrajudicial sanction), which are presumed to be enough for a first non-violent offence. In Quebec, these are often handled by community justice organizations. A youth record has strict access rules, and access ends after set periods (for example, 2 years after an extrajudicial sanction is agreed to).
The letter from the store asking for money
Some stores, through a recovery company, send a letter demanding a few hundred dollars for their costs. This is a civil claim, separate from the criminal case:
- Paying it does not stop a criminal charge.
- Not paying it does not create a new criminal charge.
- The store would have to sue you in civil court to force payment. If it does and you ignore the claim, the court can order you to pay.
Ask a lawyer before paying, especially if the amount seems out of proportion to what was taken.
When to get a lawyer
A short consultation is worth it if:
- you received a court date or a paper to appear for fingerprints;
- you want to ask for diversion or a discharge;
- you are not a Canadian citizen, or you travel to the U.S. often;
- you already have a record, or the value is high;
- you were accused of using force or resisting security.
On JustiConnect you can compare theft and property crime lawyers in Quebec and book a consultation, or find a shoplifting lawyer near you.
Charged in the Ottawa area? You can also compare criminal defence lawyers in Ottawa.
Frequently asked questions
Is shoplifting a crime in Canada?
Yes. It is theft under the Criminal Code, a federal law that applies in every province, no matter how small the item.
Can you go to jail for shoplifting in Canada?
Yes, it is possible: up to two years for theft of $5,000 or less. But for a first, low-value theft, jail is rare. Diversion, a discharge, a fine or probation are much more common.
Will a first shoplifting offence give me a criminal record?
Not necessarily. If you complete a diversion program (Quebec's PMRG or Ontario's Direct Accountability Program), the charge is dismissed (Quebec) or withdrawn (Ontario). A discharge is also not a conviction and is removed from the RCMP national database after 1 or 3 years.
Can store security keep me until the police arrive?
Yes. The owner or someone they authorize can arrest a person caught stealing on the property, but must hand them over to police right away and can only use the force that is necessary.
Can I be charged after leaving the store?
Yes. Stores often use camera footage and report the theft later. For a summary charge, the prosecutor has 12 months; after that, only an indictment is possible.
Should I pay the store's demand letter?
Paying is your choice, but it does not end the criminal case. Get advice first.
What is the difference between theft and robbery?
Theft is taking something without permission. Robbery is theft with violence or threats, and it is much more serious. Pushing a guard to escape can turn a shoplifting case into a robbery charge.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For advice on your situation, speak with a lawyer.